Welcome to Marie Eiffel Market
Nestled in Shelter Island, Marie Eiffel Market is a charming harbor-side café and market, perfect for a delightful culinary experience. Known for its inviting atmosphere and picturesque back patio overlooking the docks, the market serves fresh French pastries, gourmet sandwiches, and exquisite desserts, including a renowned peach tarte Tatin. Customers rave about the delicious, meticulously prepared dishes made from top-quality ingredients. While the space can get busy, the efficient staff ensures quick service without sacrificing quality. With outdoor seating that's dog-friendly, it's an ideal spot for savoring delightful fare while soaking in the breathtaking waterfront views.
-
184 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, United States Hotline: +1 631-749-0003
If you’re seeking a delightful culinary escape, look no further than Marie Eiffel Market—a charming gem located at 184 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY. This quaint market and eatery perfectly blends the essence of a classic French café with the casual vibe of a local market, creating an inviting atmosphere for both locals and visitors alike.
The real star at Marie Eiffel Market is undoubtedly the food. Customers rave about the gourmet fare and the meticulous attention to detail in every dish. From freshly baked French pastries to expertly crafted sandwiches, the menu offers something for everyone. One standout is the peach tarte tatin, praised for its flaky crust and expertly caramelized fruit—perfect for sharing or indulging solo.
Those craving breakfast will be in heaven. Many patrons commend the bakery items, particularly the sweet croissants filled with cheese or chocolate—an indulgence worth every calorie. It’s the kind of place where you start with a flaky pastry and a smooth coffee, then find yourself tempted to taste everything on the menu.
But the true experience goes beyond just the food. Dining outdoors on the back patio offers stunning views of the harbor, where sailboats sway gently in the breeze. Customers love the atmosphere—an ideal setting that amplifies the pleasure of every bite. The outdoor seating is dog-friendly too, so your furry friends can join in on the fun.
The friendly staff enhances the experience, creating a warm and vibrant environment that feels like home. Customers have noted how the team, led by owner Marie, goes above and beyond to ensure a wonderful experience.
While some may find the prices a touch higher due to its exclusive location, the quality of the ingredients and the unique shopping experience—from locally sourced products to a variety of gourmet goods—makes it well worth the visit.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick bagel and coffee, enjoying a leisurely lunch, or indulging in sweet treats on the patio, Marie Eiffel Market promises a memorable experience infused with French flair and community charm. Make sure to stop by during your next visit to Shelter Island—you won’t regret it!
The perfect little market/restaurant. The view from back patio area on the docks is gorgeous. The staff was fun and inviting, and the food was delicious!
Went here for breakfast... AMAZING! If you're looking for French pastry, you've found it.
Love this place! Must have a sweet croissant, cheese or chocolate....worth every calorie. Outdoor seating that's dog friendly too.
Quaint locale. The food was delicious and meticulously prepared. All of the ingredients were top notch and extremely fresh. They have a small market where the locals shop for varied food items. It was a bit expensive but it’s in a very exclusive neighborhood so it was expected. I’d definitely go back.
Cute little harbor side cafe/grab and go store. The bakery items are fresh and you can see the staff constantly putting out new things from the kitchen. It was a little chaotic in there, super busy, with tons of people waiting for their food, but the food came out quickly. You can grab your order and sit at the outdoor deck which was right on the harbor. The table and chairs are bare bones. You clean your own tables and there’s no service out there. The highlight was the peach tart tartin - which is huge and meant for 2 (or 3) and it was delicious flaky crust and the fruit was caramelized to perfection
Delicious gourmet fare in a quaint French shop with a back patio overlooking sailboats docked in a harbor. Doesn’t get better than this! We recommend the roasted veggies, pizzas, and don’t forget the tarte tartin. Magnifique.
Stopped in for a quick bagel and coffee. Both were delicious! We sat outside on the water and enjoyed the view.
We had lunch there as we heard that it was a great place to eat. I was not disappointed at all! We all had sandwiches et it was really good. The owner Marie was very friendly with us same as the staff. I would totally recommend this place if you want a great lunch!